I have a couple domains with mail maps working correctly, but they were setup a long time ago. For the new one, I am using a wildcard (*) and sending it to a gmail account. I am checking other DNS servers and the MX record is pointing to mx-caprica.zoneedit.com. I have also checked spam and my tests are sending from outlook.com. Am I missing anything else that I might have done years ago for email forwarding that is not working on the new one?